As we all know, The Rules and Bylaws Committee of the Democratic National Committee met on Saturday to rule on the issue of the Florida and Michigan primaries.
There was never going to be a good way to resolve these issues, which were in part created by the state parties of Florida and Michigan. Under any scenario, the only conclusions the Rules committee could reach would be one in which some people would be unhappy. In the end, Democrats reached the same conclusion that Republicans reached - a 50% penalty for all delegates from each state.
The decision of the Rules committee did not seal the fate of the Clinton campaign. If the delegates from Florida and Michigan were seated 100%, Senator Clinton would still trail Senator Obama by nearly 100 delegates. At this point, even that math is insurmountable.
The Rules Committee voted internally by a decision of 14-13 that Michigan's delegates should be apportioned evenly to each candidate. But in the interest of Party unity, this measure was not pursued and instead the RBC went with Michigan's proposal: 69 votes for Senator Clinton, 59 votes for Senator Obama (subsequently reduced by half, amounting to 34.5 and 29.5 votes respectively).
My colleague, Harold Ickes, has voiced his displeasure on the
Michigan ruling and has said that the path to unity doesn't start by
taking away 4 delegates - though I disagree. The path to unity actually started with the decision to seat any delegates.
Things I'd liked to have seen: A presentation from a state that wanted to go earlier in the cycle but opted not to do so, any alternative solutions proposed by the two states to fix the problem (as it stands, they only rejected solutions proposed by the DNC).
I also would have preferred that the penalty be a reduction in the size of the delegations by 50%, as opposed to the recommendation which is to seat the full delegations but reduce the voting strength by 50%. Seating the entire delegation doesn't offer any accountability for bad behavior.
Now the magic number is 2117, which Senator Obama will likely reach by the time the last poll closes in Montana on Tuesday night. Our Party needs to unify immediately. A candidate challenge to take
this motion to the national convention undermines Party unity and our
chances to win in November.
Recent Comments